Rate The Celebs - Round 1 - E. Watson, E. Roberts, E. Stone

[Nightshade]

Hello and welcome to my Rate The Celebs thread series.

Since I have now lost faith in the polls forum due to people rigging the votes constantly and the whole thing losing any credibility and honesty, I decided to try and resurrect a thread series created by a user I can't remember the name of, few months ago before the forums crushed. Those threads got deleted when the forums were recovered. I liked the idea and would like to revive it and continue it as long as possible.

How it works:
Each thread in the series will feature 3 celebrities. The thread will revolve around their fighting capabilities of course, and you will have the following attributes to rate:

Strength - Overall physical stregth.
Endurance - How much punishment she can endure.
Speed - How agile and quick she is.
Fitness - How fit she is and how long she can keep fighting before getting tired.
Abs - How strong are her abs.
Skill - Overall skill at fighting. This has nothing to do with any of the other attributes, just how well she knows how to fight.
Intelligence - How clever she is when fighting.
Toughness - How mentally tough she is, how easy it is to break her mentally and make her give up or cry etc.
Ferocity - How fierce she is when she fights.

*Optional visual attributes:
Beauty - How pretty she is.
Body - How hot her body is.

In addition, after rating each girl's attributes, please rank the 3 girls from best fighter overall to worst fighter overall in your opinion.
Also, feel free to add your written thoughts about each girl or how they compare.

Each attribute can be rated from 1 to 10 (you can also give half scores i.e 7.5)
1 = The weakest possible for a human
2 = Pathetically weak
3 = Very weak
4 = Weak
5 = Average
6 = Slightly above average
7 = Pretty strong
8 = Strong
9 = Very strong
10 = Amazingly strong

After collecting enough responses I will post a final evaluation of the girls with the average scores from everyone.

Thanks for participating!
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To start things off, I chose the classic battle of the Emmas!

ROUND 1
Emma Watson vs Emma Roberts vs Emma Stone

Emma Watson (27 y/o, 5'6, 111 lbs)


-------------------

Emma Roberts (26 y/o, 5'2, 104 lbs)


-------------------

Emma Stone (28 y/o, 5'6, 109 lbs)

[Nightshade]

Starting things off with my own ratings:

Emma Watson

Strength - 4
Endurance - 4
Speed - 7.5
Fitness - 7
Abs - 7.5
Skill - 5.5
Intelligence - 8
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 7

Beauty - 8.5
Body - 7

Emma Roberts

Strength - 3.5
Endurance - 4
Speed - 7
Fitness - 7
Abs - 7
Skill - 5
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 6
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 8.5
Body - 7

Emma Stone

Strength - 3
Endurance - 3.5
Speed - 6
Fitness - 5.5
Abs - 5
Skill - 4.5
Intelligence - 8.5
Toughness - 7.5
Ferocity - 4.5

Beauty - 8
Body - 6

Overall Best Fighter to Worst Fighter:
1. Emma Watson
2. Emma Roberts
3. Emma Stone

[Vitezislav]

Emma Watson

Strength - 4.5
Endurance - 5.5
Speed - 6
Fitness - 6.5
Abs - 4
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 6.5
Ferocity - 7

Beauty - 6.5
Body - 6

Emma Roberts

Strength - 5.5
Endurance - 6
Speed - 6
Fitness - 6.5
Abs - 5
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 7
Body - 7

Emma Stone

Strength - 4
Endurance - 4.5
Speed - 5
Fitness - 5
Abs - 3
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 5
Ferocity - 5

Beauty - 5
Body - 5


Overall Best Fighter to Worst Fighter:
1. Emma Roberts
2. Emma Watson
3. Emma Stone

[890]

Emma Watson

Strength - 4
Endurance - 4
Speed - 6
Fitness - 6.5
Abs - 5
Skill - 3
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 4
Ferocity - 3

Beauty - 6
Body - 7

Emma Roberts

Strength - 5
Endurance - 6
Speed - 6
Fitness - 6
Abs - 5
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 7
Body - 6

Emma Stone

Strength - 6
Endurance - 5.5
Speed - 7
Fitness - 5
Abs - 6
Skill - 7
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 6
Body - 7.5


Overall Best Fighter to Worst Fighter:
1. Emma Stone             *2+
2. Emma Roberts          *1
3. Emma Watson          *3


*rating is my preference based on attractiveness.
+Stone's ass in yoga pants was the decisive factor in her over Watson

[Nightshade]

Do a KATE round. Kate Upton, Kate beckinsale and Kate hudson

How about you participate first and then I can take your request more seriously?
Just asking for something else without even bothering to participate doesn't exactly make me want to do what you ask.

[Vitezislav]

Do a KATE round. Kate Upton, Kate beckinsale and Kate hudson

How about you participate first and then I can take your request more seriously?
Just asking for something else without even bothering to participate doesn't exactly make me want to do what you ask.

He also keeps asking about Miley Cyrus vs Kate Beckinsale story everywhere. I don't see any reason why someone would write a fight about those two. They have nothing in common.

[VanHelsing]

Emma Watson

Strength - 5.5
Endurance - 6
Speed - 7
Fitness - 7
Abs - 5
Skill - 7
Intelligence - 8
Toughness - 6.5
Ferocity - 5

Beauty - 8
Body - 7

Emma Roberts

Strength - 6
Endurance - 6
Speed - 6
Fitness - 6
Abs - 5
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 6.5
Toughness - 4
Ferocity - 4

Beauty - 6
Body - 7

Emma Stone

Strength - 7
Endurance - 4
Speed - 4
Fitness - 4
Abs - 3
Skill - 5
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 8
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 7
Body - 8


Overall Best Fighter to Worst Fighter:
1. Emma Watson
2. Emma Stone
3. Emma Roberts

Watson is weakest overall but makes it up with her wit, skills and athletics to take first place. Stone has some fitness issues but her natural strength and ferocity give her win over Roberts. Roberts has solid body and strength but I don't think she would have enough skill or spirit to win a fight against other Emmas.

Ps Great idea. Keep doing this !!!

[LizKO]

Emma Watson
Strength - 4
Endurance - 5
Speed - 7
Fitness - 7
Abs - 3
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 8
Toughness - 6
Ferocity - 5

Beauty - 8
Body - 6

Emma Roberts
Strength - 6
Endurance - 6
Speed - 7
Fitness - 7
Abs - 5
Skill - 5
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 6
Ferocity - 8

Beauty - 7
Body - 7

Emma Stone
Strength - 5
Endurance - 5
Speed - 6
Fitness - 5
Abs - 3
Skill - 7
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 8
Ferocity - 5

Beauty - 9
Body - 6

Overall Best Fighter to Worst Fighter:
1. Emma Roberts
2. Emma Watson
3. Emma Stone

I think you're all underestimating Roberts here especially given her "ferocious" history. She's also got family pedigree which gives her a bit of an edge, especially with her aunt in her corner. Stone is definitely the beauty in the group, I can't believe anyone would argue otherwise. I don't think she's as terrible in a fight as some of you are making her out to be but she's definitely the weakest contender in the group.

[Nightshade]

I think you're all underestimating Roberts here especially given her "ferocious" history. She's also got family pedigree which gives her a bit of an edge, especially with her aunt in her corner. Stone is definitely the beauty in the group, I can't believe anyone would argue otherwise. I don't think she's as terrible in a fight as some of you are making her out to be but she's definitely the weakest contender in the group.

I'm not underestimating Roberts as I put her 2nd but I think you're over-estimating her strength, considering she is the smallest of the three, I don't think its likely shes stronger than Watson and even if she is, not by a full 2 points

But this is why this thread exists, to see what other people think about these girls, so its all good and thank you for participating and adding your thoughts!

[Xtra164]

Great concept and execution in this thread! My personal rankings (side note-my Total Points for each girl doesn't include Beauty and Body categories):

Emma Watson

Strength - 4
Endurance - 4
Speed - 7
Fitness - 5
Abs - 3
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 6
Toughness - 4
Ferocity - 4

Beauty - 9
Body - 8

Total Points: 41

Emma Roberts

Strength - 6
Endurance - 6
Speed - 7
Fitness - 5
Abs - 4
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 6
Ferocity - 7

Beauty - 7
Body - 7

Total Points: 54

Emma Stone

Strength - 6
Endurance - 7
Speed - 6
Fitness - 7
Abs - 5
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 6

Beauty - 9
Body - 8

Total Points: 57

1. Emma Stone
2. Emma Roberts
3. Emma Watson

I guess I'm in the minority on this one but I think Stone has moxie and can carry herself in a fight. I think she edges out Roberts who benefits from her family history in Hollywood and knows how cutthroat the business is. And while I wouldn't call Watson a complete jobber, I've always thought she was overrated by many and the clear weakest link here. I could see her as being one of those girls that comes in with a haughty attitude but can't quite back it up in the ring if she's facing someone legitimate. So both other Emma's take Watson down with relative ease and Stone narrowly pulls it out against Roberts.

[Nightshade]

Great concept and execution in this thread! My personal rankings (side note-my Total Points for each girl doesn't include Beauty and Body categories):

I guess I'm in the minority on this one but I think Stone has moxie and can carry herself in a fight. I think she edges out Roberts who benefits from her family history in Hollywood and knows how cutthroat the business is. And while I wouldn't call Watson a complete jobber, I've always thought she was overrated by many and the clear weakest link here. I could see her as being one of those girls that comes in with a haughty attitude but can't quite back it up in the ring if she's facing someone legitimate. So both other Emma's take Watson down with relative ease and Stone narrowly pulls it out against Roberts.

Thanks for the compliments and participation!
I guess I can see how you could come to these conclusions and can understand most ratings you gave but one thing I cannot - how can you say Stone is more fit than Watson or Roberts? and by 2 whole points! To me her body looks way "softer" than the other two. What am I missing? I'd love to hear your thought behind that.

[WrestleFuck]

Emma Watson:
Strength - 5.5
Endurance - 6
Speed - 8
Fitness - 7.5
Abs - 5.5
Skill - 6
Intelligence - 9
Toughness - 4.5
Ferocity - 4

Beauty - 10
Body - 7.5

Total Points: 56

Emma Roberts:
Strength - 6
Endurance - 5.5
Speed - 7
Fitness - 6
Abs - 5
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 4.5
Toughness - 4
Ferocity - 6.5

Beauty - 8
Body - 7.5

Total Points: 48.5

Emma Stone:
Strength - 3
Endurance - 4
Speed - 4.5
Fitness - 4
Abs - 3
Skill - 4
Intelligence - 3.5
Toughness - 2.5
Ferocity - 4

Beauty - 3.5
Body - 4

Total Points: 32.5

1. Watson
2. Roberts
3. Stone

[GramerJew123]

Emma Watson:
Strength - 5
Endurance - 4
Speed - 5
Fitness - 5.5
Abs - 5.5
Skill - 3
Intelligence - 8
Toughness - 4
Ferocity - 5

Beauty - 7
Body - 7

Total Points: 45

Emma Roberts:
Strength -6.5
Endurance - 5.5
Speed - 7
Fitness - 6
Abs - 6.5
Skill - 3
Intelligence - 4.5
Toughness - 7
Ferocity - 7

Beauty - 6
Body - 7

Total Points: 54

Emma Stone:
Strength - 4.5
Endurance - 4
Speed - 5
Fitness - 5.5
Abs - 4.5
Skill - 3
Intelligence - 7
Toughness - 6
Ferocity - 6

Beauty - 8.5
Body - 6

Total Points: 44.5

Overall Fighter Rankings
1. Roberts
2. Stone
3. Watson (Intelligence does not really matter in a fight besides when taunting which does not take that much intelligence but rather info)

Didn't count beauty or body