Which woman will win the most often: fat or slim ?

[rozczochrany]

Hatred between families will bring to women's fight from both families. If it will come to wild catfight of families (There have not  helps family. Mother fights with mother only. Daughter fights with daughter only.) them which woman will win? 

Second question:
How you think. Two women are in similar age and similar growth. Which woman will win in brutal real fight the most often? Fat or slim?

I invite to writing and motivating your opinions  thereon subject.

Smith:

Kate   -  age: 46  height: 5'4" ( 163 cm )  weight: 124 lb ( 58 kg ) :

 


Kely  -  age: 18  height: 5'5" ( 164 cm )  weight: 118 lb ( 56 kg ) :





Jones:

Tara   -  age: 45  height: 5'4" ( 163 cm )  weight: 167 lb ( 75 kg ) :



Grace  -  age: 19  height: 5'3" ( 162 cm )  weight: 132lb ( 60 kg ) :

[CrashCorrigan]

The problem with this poll is the restriction that mother will only fight mother, and daughter will only fight daughter.  Would be better for me if it was mother against daughter, their own or the other mom's daughter.  This could have been made an option or it could have been a round robin kind of tournament.  For example, what happens if Tara beats Kate and Kely beats Grace?  Then Tara and Kely could fight and Kate could fight Grace.  Then maybe each pair of mom and daughter get angry with each other and Kate fights Kely and Tara fights Grace.  More options are always better than less. 

[Zulu]

My overall feeling is the Jones family are tougher

[martha]

Tara is more sexyes and stronger than kate, Tara will beat Kate, but betven daughters   hhhmmmmmm Kelly se beter than Grace, Kelly will beat Grace.

[cattleman]

the jones family do look the better but hey what does a rancher now. would love to see it though

[catullus]

Fat women are good in a fight only when they are muscled. Slim women use to go faster. See for example in a judo match...
Btw, here I bet that Grace would defeat Kely and that Kate would defeat Tara. So, for me, it would be tie.