. . . . . . good girl vs bad girl, rolling (catball), hairpulling catfight? It may not be everyone's taste, but for those who like the idea, here are some specifics.
The good girl gets much the worst of it but courageously fights to the bitter end, no matter what she must endure. She never gives!! If settled by a panel of judges (awarding the win/points) they'd clearly have to call it for the bad girl. If there has to be a verbal submission though it's a different story. There is no admission of defeat.
Does the good girl win by bravely refusing to concede? Or is it maybe a stalemate? Then after a particularly vicious brawl they each go their separate ways, on bad terms, and have a rematch later.
Any celebrity from any time, and (ideally) at her/their peak.
Quote from: DKBfb1 on October 12, 2022, 09:58:25 PM
. . . . . . good girl vs bad girl, rolling (catball), hairpulling catfight? It may not be everyone's taste, but for those who like the idea, here are some specifics.
The good girl gets much the worst of it but courageously fights to the bitter end, no matter what she must endure. She never gives!! If settled by a panel of judges (awarding the win/points) they'd clearly have to call it for the bad girl. If there has to be a verbal submission though it's a different story. There is no admission of defeat.
Does the good girl win by bravely refusing to concede? Or is it maybe a stalemate? Then after a particularly vicious brawl they each go their separate ways, on bad terms, and have a rematch later.
Any celebrity from any time, and (ideally) at her/their peak.
Classic: Raquel Welch (bad girl) vs Sophia Loren (good girl)
Raquel Welch (Bad girl) vs Ann Margaret (good girl)
Lynda Carter (bad girl) vs Catherine Bach (good girl)
Jenny McCarthy (bad girl) vs Debbe Dunning (good girl)
Current: Kaley Cuoco (bad girl) vs Jessica Biel (good girl)
Salma Hayek (good girl) vs Eva Longoria (bad girl)
Jennifer Connelly (good girl) vs Courteney Cox (bad girl)
That's a great scenario! Here are my suggestions:
1) Kat Dennings (bad girl) vs Natalie Portman (good girl);
2) Margot Robbie (bad girl) vs Elizabeth Olsen (good girl);
3) Anne Hathaway (good girl) vs Kate Beckinsale (bad girl);
4) Vanessa Hudgens (bad girl) vs Ashley Tisdale (good girl);
5) Troian Bellisario (bad girl) vs Naomi Scott (good girl);
6) Alison Brie (bad girl) vs Gillian Jacobs (good girl);
7) Sofia Vergara (bad girl) vs Heidi Klum (good girl);
Quote from: Edududu on October 12, 2022, 10:35:33 PM
That's a great scenario! Here are my suggestions:
1) Kat Dennings (bad girl) vs Natalie Portman (good girl);
2) Margot Robbie (bad girl) vs Elizabeth Olsen (good girl);
3) Anne Hathaway (good girl) vs Kate Beckinsale (bad girl);
4) Vanessa Hudgens (bad girl) vs Ashley Tisdale (good girl);
5) Troian Bellisario (bad girl) vs Naomi Scott (good girl);
6) Alison Brie (bad girl) vs Gillian Jacobs (good girl);
7) Sofia Vergara (bad girl) vs Heidi Klum (good girl);
Couple more:
Kat Dennings (good girl) vs Scarlett Johannson (bad girl)
Vanessa Hudgens (bad girl) vs Mila Kunis (good girl)
Dana Delaney (good girl) vs Susan Sarandon (bad girl)
Julie Bowen (good girl) vs Jennifer Aniston (bad girl)
Quote from: Edududu on October 12, 2022, 10:35:33 PM
That's a great scenario! Here are my suggestions:
1) Kat Dennings (bad girl) vs Natalie Portman (good girl);
2) Margot Robbie (bad girl) vs Elizabeth Olsen (good girl);
3) Anne Hathaway (good girl) vs Kate Beckinsale (bad girl);
4) Vanessa Hudgens (bad girl) vs Ashley Tisdale (good girl);
5) Troian Bellisario (bad girl) vs Naomi Scott (good girl);
6) Alison Brie (bad girl) vs Gillian Jacobs (good girl);
7) Sofia Vergara (bad girl) vs Heidi Klum (good girl);
7 fantastic suggestions!!! My runaway fav is number 3 but with the good girl and bad girl roles swapped. It's not that I particularly see Anne Hathaway as a bad girl, it's just that Kate Beckinsale is my 100% good girl of all time. I couldn't imagine it any other way. Other than that though it's an exciting cast!! Plenty of new bad girl options for Kate to fight.
Quote from: sinclairfan on October 12, 2022, 10:58:23 PM
Heather Thomas (bad girl) vs Heather Locklear (good girl--so, the T.J.Hooker version of her)
Heather Locklear in her TJ Hooker cop uniform? Magnificent!!! :)
I'm sure a lot of my choices for good girl/bad girl will be the opposite of most people's opinions, but that's how I like it.
Current:
Ariana Grande (good) vs Victoria Justice (bad)
Kristen Stewart (good) vs Anna Kendrick (bad)
Megan Fox (good) vs Sydney Sweeney (bad)
Amber Heard (good) Liz Gillies (bad)
Emma Roberts (good) vs Emma Stone (bad)
Rooney Mara (good) vs Kristen Bell (bad)
Mary Winstead (good) vs Blake Lively (bad)
Alicia Vikander (good) vs Margot Robbie (bad)
Early 00's:
Liz Hurley (good) vs Jennifer Connelly (bad)
Eliza Dushku (good) vs Jessica Albe (bad)
Evangeline Lilly (good) vs Jaime Pressley or Ali Larter (bad)
And the bad girls should always win.
Quote from: sinclairfan on October 13, 2022, 03:50:00 PM
Mary Winstead is a "good call", as she has had a long career in both good and bad girl roles. Can you believe that was her in 'Fargo'?!
Having said that, Blake Lively deserves a more vicious rival. Maybe Rose McGowan?
Jennie Garth was both a 'bad Kelly Taylor' and a 'good Kelly Taylor' at various seasons of '90210'.
Tiffani Thiessen was as-good-as-a-girl-can-be on 'Saved by the Bell', and as-bad-as-a-girl-can-be on '90210'. Bad-Valerie-Malone versus bad-Kelly-Taylor would have been an epic brawl.
Robert Redford's secret sauce when he directed 'Ordinary People' in 1980 was to cast Mary Tyler Moore, an iconic good girl, as a cold-hearted bitch of a mother. The ending of the movie was shocking because no one in 1980 could reconcile the character MTM played with their image of MTM the actress.
Agree totally on bad Jennie Garth (Kelly Taylor) vs bad Tiffani Thiessen (Valerie Malone) on BH90210. What a fight that would have been. I favor Tiffani to finally win it. Also:
1) Good girl Tiffani Thiessen (Kelly Kapowski (Saved by the Bell)) vs bad girl Elizabeth Berkley (Jessie Spanos)
2) Mary Tyler Moore (bad girl) vs Lee Meriweather (good girl (Barnaby Jones))
3) Elizabeth Berkley (bad girl) vs Brooke Shields (good girl)
4) Patricia Heaton (good girl (Everybody Loves Raymond) vs Katie Couric (bad girl)
5) Diane Sawyer (bad girl) vs Joan Lunden (good girl)
I love the good girl vs bad girl scenario. With the good girl who is clearly defeated.
My choices would be:
Alexa Chung (good girl) vs Kate Hupton (bad girl)
Natalia Dyer (good girl) vs Jessica Biel (bad girl)
Victoria Justice (good girl) vs Kaley Cuoco (bad girl)
Lily Rose Depp (good girl) vs Hilary Swank (bad girl)
Ariana Grande (good girl) vs Gwen Stefani (bad girl)
Maya Hawke (good girl) vs Mel B (bad girl)
Emma Stone (good girl) vs Gal Gadot (bad girl)
Late 70s:
Susan Anton (bad) vs Pam Grier (good)
(https://geeksoncoffee.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Susan-Anton-sexy-bikini.jpeg)
(https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-OR-e_dSfq94/XaNOgPG80mI/AAAAAAACGSs/zaLdHp8_21sHhgXYiBWzQmKAI-xM2bZ1QCLcBGAsYHQ/s1600/pam-grier-15.jpg)
Donna Dixon (bad) vs Catherine Bach (good)
(https://i0.wp.com/comicbooksgalaxy.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Donna-Dixon-sexy-pic.jpeg?resize=696%2C835&ssl=1)
(https://i1.wp.com/comicbooksgalaxy.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Catherine-Bach-30.jpeg?resize=696%2C866&ssl=1)
Priscilla Barnes (bad) vs Marcia Strassman (good)
(https://iv1.lisimg.com/image/13149536/740full-priscilla-barnes.jpg)
(https://scontent-lga3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.6435-9/167910124_1033732553823041_3082690203194669515_n.jpg?_nc_cat=106&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=730e14&_nc_ohc=256wrG0V-fgAX9_Ii_Z&_nc_ht=scontent-lga3-1.xx&oh=00_AT9wG0aZP51Q_kBSndgDksEE2cJYnx6hdzvVVKnf4E5Q0w&oe=637313EA)
Barbi Benton (bad) vs Lydia Cornell (good)
(https://iv1.lisimg.com/image/7597066/424full-barbi-benton.jpg)
(https://iv1.lisimg.com/image/6740337/740full-lydia-cornell.jpg)
Marilyn Monroe good vs Jane Russell (bad
I love Good Girl/Bad Girl matchups. Unlike most of you though, I generally like to imagine the bad girl picking a fight and getting taught some manners by the good girl. Anyways, here are some of my favorite celeb matchups...
Charlize Theron (Bad) Jessica Biel (Good)
Jaime Pressly (Bad) Kelly Monaco (Good)
Debbe Dunning (Bad) Erika Eleniak (Good)
Jenny McCarthy (Bad) Sofia Vergara (Good)
Lynda Carter (Bad) Cybill Shepherd (Good)
Serinda Swan (Bad) Laura Vandervoort (Good)
Raquel Welch (Bad) Linda Evans (Good)
Heather Thomas (Bad) Catherine Bach (Good)
Deborah Shelton (Bad) Donna Dixon (Good)
Charisma Carpenter (Bad) Kayley Cuoco (good)
Quote from: Attaguy on October 18, 2022, 04:12:57 PM
I love Good Girl/Bad Girl matchups. Unlike most of you though, I generally like to imagine the bad girl picking a fight and getting taught some manners by the good girl. Anyways, here are some of my favorite celeb matchups...
Charlize Theron (Bad) Jessica Biel (Good)
Jaime Pressly (Bad) Kelly Monaco (Good)
Debbe Dunning (Bad) Erika Eleniak (Good)
Jenny McCarthy (Bad) Sofia Vergara (Good)
Lynda Carter (Bad) Cybill Shepherd (Good)
Serinda Swan (Bad) Laura Vandervoort (Good)
Raquel Welch (Bad) Linda Evans (Good)
Heather Thomas (Bad) Catherine Bach (Good)
Deborah Shelton (Bad) Donna Dixon (Good)
Charisma Carpenter (Bad) Kayley Cuoco (good)
I would add a couple more to the list:
Farrah Fawcett (Bad) Jacklyn Smith (Good)
Tanya Roberts (Bad) Lynda Carter (good)
Olivia Newton John (Bad) Pam Dawber (good)
Not sure the good girls will win all the fights. I might also flip the good/bad monikers between Dunning and Eleniak. All would be exciting and entertaining to watch.
Quote from: VAKris on October 18, 2022, 05:55:03 PM
Quote from: Attaguy on October 18, 2022, 04:12:57 PM
I love Good Girl/Bad Girl matchups. Unlike most of you though, I generally like to imagine the bad girl picking a fight and getting taught some manners by the good girl. Anyways, here are some of my favorite celeb matchups...
Charlize Theron (Bad) Jessica Biel (Good)
Jaime Pressly (Bad) Kelly Monaco (Good)
Debbe Dunning (Bad) Erika Eleniak (Good)
Jenny McCarthy (Bad) Sofia Vergara (Good)
Lynda Carter (Bad) Cybill Shepherd (Good)
Serinda Swan (Bad) Laura Vandervoort (Good)
Raquel Welch (Bad) Linda Evans (Good)
Heather Thomas (Bad) Catherine Bach (Good)
Deborah Shelton (Bad) Donna Dixon (Good)
Charisma Carpenter (Bad) Kayley Cuoco (good)
I would add a couple more to the list:
Farrah Fawcett (Bad) Jacklyn Smith (Good)
Tanya Roberts (Bad) Lynda Carter (good)
Olivia Newton John (Bad) Pam Dawber (good)
Not sure the good girls will win all the fights. I might also flip the good/bad monikers between Dunning and Eleniak. All would be exciting and entertaining to watch.
I also like sometimes going against the grain with a bit of opposite casting, mind-you, some of these match-ups make it necessary
Catherine Bach (Good) ? ... then again, as it's vs. Heather Thomas, it works !
Lynda Carter (Bad) ? & Cybill Shepherd (Good) ? Personally, I see Shepherd being much more the bitch queen from hell type than Lynda. In this case, it could even affect the outcome: (Bad) Lynda would probably take (Good) Cybill, but, if it's the reverse and (Bad) Shepherd comes out swinging low and dirty right from the start, then Good'' Lynda may just go down.
My favorite is Olivia Newton John vs. Pam Dawber, but, Olivia (Bad) ? ... well, again, consider who she's facing here, vs. perhaps the ultimate goodie that is Pam, then even a woman like Olivia could seem like the baddie and she has shown that she does have SOME character, where as Pam deems devoid of any.
Back when I used to write catfight stories, those goodie vs goodie ones were often the most fun to do, but the hardest to get started (the "why" of it, how does it go beyond a verbal argument, then goes one step further after it becomes a shoving match)
Just to finish up on that, one of my favorite cases among the rare opposite-casting that I've considered over the years is Olivia vs. Madonna, with Olivia being the nasty and able fighter, dressed sexily (stockings ect) and Madonna as a prude woman, dressed like the cliché demure housewife (right down to dingy K-Mart pantyhose) who's the type to run to the showers the second that she's on the receiving end of two consecutive face-slaps... not that wicked Olivia would ever leave her off that easy...
Country Music matchups
Carrie Underwood/Good vs Miranda Lambert/Bad
(https://i.ibb.co/qgmfWmY/Carrie-Underwood-TA-094.jpg)(https://i.ibb.co/9sy7yK3/7f2f601e056f5858907556e7db08dec9-lg.jpg)
Faith Hill/Good vs Shania Twain/Bad
(https://i.ibb.co/C1fy57m/Y9-Rhf01-X-o4.jpg)
(https://i.ibb.co/DWN35g1/z100s-5th-annual-jingle-ball-december-17-1998-14.jpg)
Carly Pearce/Good vs Maren Morris/Bad
(https://i.ibb.co/4ddyZ5J/carly-pearce.jpg)
(https://i.ibb.co/Qn1fN86/maren-morris-billboard-magazine-2015-0025.jpg)
This:
Julie Bowen (good girl) vs Jennifer Aniston (bad girl)
Pam Grier (bad girl) vs Adrienne Barbeau (good girl)
Sofia Vegara (bad girl) vs Cristina Hendricks (good girl)
Sybil Danning (bad girl) vs Linda Carter (good girl)
Late 80s/early 90s:
Danielle Brisebois (good) vs OIivia D'Abo (bad)
(https://i.discogs.com/cy9_qQsd75uYm8Ws8CcCvfSJETe-Er_Yyxjzc9NGmzw/rs:fit/g:sm/q:90/h:526/w:600/czM6Ly9kaXNjb2dz/LWRhdGFiYXNlLWlt/YWdlcy9SLTcyNjEx/Ny0xNDQyMjE2MDEz/LTE5MTIuanBlZw.jpeg)
(https://happybday.to/sites/pics/danielle-brisebois-all-in-the-family-2.jpg)
(https://i.pinimg.com/736x/b2/90/11/b29011013f1dabbf70f44e8ce5580f8b--olivia-dabo-star-trek.jpg)
(https://iv1.lisimg.com/image/969854/381full-olivia-d'abo.jpg)